A plan to demolish a block of homes in Chelsea is being objected to by The Victorian Society.

Affinity Sutton Group has submitted a planning application to demolish Sutton Estate , formerly known as Sutton Dwellings - which was the biggest social housing scheme in London when built in 1913.

According to the society, which champions Victorian and Edwardian buildings in England and Wales, Affinity’s replacement social and private scheme would provide less social housing.

Members argue the existing flats should not be demolished, but refurbished instead.

It said: “The proposed replacement buildings are bland and lack the character of the 1913 buildings. It has been suggested that housing created by philanthropic trusts in Chelsea are — in both architectural and human terms — far more successful that most later council housing.

“Affinity Sutton should celebrate the success of these buildings by investing in their future. Affinity should perhaps explore the option of redeveloping some flats for private sale to raise funds for work needed elsewhere on the Sutton Estate.”

James Hughes, senior Victorian Society conservation adviser, said: “Sutton Dwellings is an early example of social housing which makes a positive contribution to the local area and sits well with the 1915 Samuel Lewis Trust Dwellings opposite.

“With its handsome proportions it is unsurprising that many residents are unhappy at leaving. While the estate has suffered from the installation of UPVC glazing this does not detract from its overall quality. Affinity should spend its money on sensitive restoration rather than demolishing this early attempt to address inequality in London.”

But Affinity Sutton defended its plans. A spokesperson said: “The accommodation no longer provides the quality of accommodation we wish to give our residents.

“We truly believe our plans are the best proposals for safeguarding the future of social housing in Chelsea. All our tenants will remain living on the estate in good quality new homes that will stand the test of time.

“They will benefit from a comprehensive package which includes a payment of just over £5,000. In addition all tenants will remain on social rent.”

She added the change in layout will result in five time more space, and a new community centre on site.

A public consultation on Affinity’s plans closed on December 11.